Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Coke Products
Chicken
Cannolli
w/ Cheese & Pepperoni
About
I Love NY Pizza & Subs
If you find yourself in Orlando, Florida, craving a slice of authentic New York-style pizza, look no further than I Love NY Pizza & Subs. Nestled at 6602 Old Winter Garden Rd, this local gem brings the heart of New York's pizzeria culture right to Central Florida.
The menu is a delight for any food lover. Indulge in their array of calzones, starting at just $8.99 for the classic Cheese & Ricotta and moving through hearty options like the Meatlover and Steak, each bubbling with flavor. If you’re feeling adventurous, you can even customize your calzone for a small additional cost.
But let’s not overlook the Strombolis, which mirror the same delightful versatility as their calzones. Priced comparably, these stuffed delights are packed with fresh ingredients, offering everything from simple cheese to bold combinations that will satisfy any palate.
Of course, no meal at I Love NY Pizza & Subs would be complete without exploring their dessert offerings. Treat yourself to a delectable Cannoli or Zappoli, both priced at $4.99. These sweet indulgences are the perfect ending to a savory meal.
Customer testimonials paint a glowing picture of the establishment, highlighting the friendly service and welcoming atmosphere. Lisa K. shared her appreciation for the nice service and timely food preparation, while Chey Chey raved about the mouthwatering wings paired perfectly with their pizza. With affordable prices and delicious options, it’s no wonder families flock to this spot!
Whether you opt for a bustling dine-in experience or a convenient takeout option, the friendly staff, many of whom are personally involved in ensuring a great dining experience, adds a personal touch reminiscent of a classic neighborhood pizzeria. The owner’s passion for food and customer satisfaction shines through, making I Love NY Pizza & Subs more than just a restaurant; it’s a place of warmth and community.
So grab your friends and family, get ready to savor the flavors of New York right here in Orlando, and prepare for a meal that will keep you coming back for more. Trust me, once you experience the deliciousness of their pizza and subs, you’ll find yourself saying, “I love NY Pizza & Subs!”
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Food was great! I'm assuming it was the owner who took our order was very nice. Food was done in the expected amount of time. Didn't wait too long. Will definitely try them again. ”
“ We were looking for a pizza spot and I'm glad this one was the first we tried. The pizza is Soooo good. The wings are mouth watering, after we finished the wings, we dipped the pizza in the leftover wing sauce(hot&lemon pepper). I cant forget to say they have great prices! THANK YOU I LOVE NY PIZZA & SUBS! ”
“ I love this place Best pizza place for me since New York, love coming here with the fam.my husband always wants to get single slices but we always end up getting more so the boss suggested to my husband that he should get a whole pie instead and there beef patty are great I always get mine playing and my husband gets his with mozzarella in it best pizza stop! ”
“ Best NY Pizza and Gyros in town fresh made to order. You can dine in do TakeOut or delivery and Staff is super firendly. ”
“ I just left there and ordered two subs and Italian and a ham. I gotta say some of the best subs I’ve had in a long time. The owner was at the register very friendly man and his employees are very friendly too. We talked for a few minutes while waiting for my food and he was very polite. Next time. I’m in Orlando on vacation. I would definitely go there again next time I think I’ll order our pizza too. ”
“ I wanted to try a different pizza place and this one always comes up on my search engine. I've been hesitant to try but finally did and they did not disappoint. I ordered through Uber Eats and the food was still piping hot even when it arrived at my house 35 mins later! The meat calzone was amazingggg. The flavor it had was great. The pizza sauce they use has a different taste from most which really made me love it here. Will definitely be back to try more menu items! ”
“ The Pizza I got was excellent wow. I’m from Jersey and wanted some good pizza I heard pizza wasn’t to good down in Florida like it is up here. I wanted something good for lunch so I opened the Uber eats app looked for something good down in Orlando and said let me try this place and see what it’s about. My first bite I was surprised how good it was. Can’t wait to get it again and try other things there. ”
“ I had a veggie calzone, it was very good. I had a small but it was so big it took me 2 days to eat it. ”